孩子的陰暗面…
陳C9: 『我個仔成日都陰陰濕濕, 做左又唔認….. 』
張C9: 『我個女明明唔開心, 又不停咁笑, 好似精神分裂咁…..』
曾經話過女兒…
佢真係好古惑呀…..
佢成日都陰陰濕濕咁….
(明明做錯野, 睇住佢錯)
問她: 『邊個唔岩呀?』
女兒: 『(指住爸B) 爸B囉!!!』
又成問女兒: 『點解您要講大話?! 您知唔知咁樣係唔岩?』
……..
…………….
……………………
直至上到這一課…. 才發現… 原來學說上有Private Self一詞!!!!
意詞並不是成人人世界的”陰陰濕濕”, “古古惑惑”, “講大話唔誠實”……
老師再三強調: 『如果你地有小朋友, 請勿驚慌, 更不用擔心, 因為呢個絕對絕對係小朋友成長既一個新階段, 佢地一定要經歷過, 先會建立起一個完整既”自我概念”, 可以做既, 就係善意的糾正佢既過錯… 就可以了!』
.
說英文的地方, 會有”I”同”ME”之分, 但中國人既語言, 什麼”I”, 什麼”ME”, 都係一個”我”字, 變相, 我地可以領略既, 可能會比較遲, 比較慢……
本來想將以下的資料翻譯成中文, 但語言能力奇差的我, 實在顯醜不如藏掘… 文字不難理解, 內容更是簡單易明…. 有興趣的好友們, 可以細看一下….
.
Public Self: people can see (both physically & mentally)
Private Self: not available for public scrutiny
By the age of 2-3
~ aware knowing something that others don’t know
~ know that their thoughts cannot be observed, reflected by (1) lying and hiding their guilt; (2) faking emotions
.
The Concept of “I” & “ME”
I: a private self that has an inner, reflective (thinking) character not available to others
ME: a public self that others can see
An 18 – 24 months old infant often use a personal pronoun (me) or their own name to label their photographic image (Lewis & Brooks-Gunn, 1979)
記: 難怪靖天見到自己個樣, 只會說”靖天”, 但極少說”我”, “我黎架”….
Early understandings of Mental States
At 18-month-old: reason accurately about other peoples’ desires (Toddlers demonstrate some awareness of their own & others’ mental states)
By the age of 2-3: often talk about mental states such as needs, feelings, desire (也許就是形成了tERRIBLE 2的問題吧?)
Between 3-4: a belief-desire theory of mind appears (Children recognize, as we adults do, those beliefs & desires are different mental states & that their or both can influence one’s conduct) (Wellman, 1990)
Example: A 4-year-old that has broken a vase while roughhousing, may try to overcome his mother’s desire to punish him by trying to make her believe that his breaking that vase was an accident
Middle Childhood (7-9 years):
~ Using more abstract or psychological attributes to represent their inner qualities (e.g. traits values, beliefs, etc)
~ Evolves from social interactions and undergoes many changes over the course of a lifetime
.
延申閱讀:
自我概念 (Self-Concept), by 明報通識網, Sept 07 (CLICK HERE)
心智理論 (Theory of Mind), by Ying0106, Jul 09 (CLICK HERE)
.
上課之所以唔眼訓, 就因為有些理論, 雖悶, 但卻正正可以應用到女兒身上….
正當靖天媽媽若干月前不停的想: 為何靖天小小年紀會說謊話? 為何心肝明明做錯而知道卻又胡說是爸B….. 原來一切, 都是這個”我“在作怪….
明白了, 知道了, 也就不再擔心, 是否教導方法出問題….
2歲的靖天, 對”我”的概念已經越來越強, 知道靖天是自己 (指指自己), 也會知道做錯的其實是自己, 亦開始承擔過錯….
但願, 遲些時間, 心肝能夠搞清楚”我”, “你”, “佢……
.
.
(360)
謝導分享~
謝謝欣賞;
之前我無研究過這個”我”的概念,但有聽過小孩並不是刻意講大話,所以面對兒子不認自己做錯既事,我會引導佢講出真相,我以為佢只係怕比人鬧而唔講,所以試過佢做錯,我叫佢勇於認錯,結果我都只會對佢作出平和的教誨,藉此同佢講做錯事唔怕認,媽媽只會教你而唔會鬧你。每次問佢,佢都唔會即時認的,係要慢慢問多幾次佢先肯講。可是,我細妹好似完全唔會站在孩子角度諗,即使早在梓塱歲幾兩歲,佢都覺得點解依家d細路咁斜惡又講大話,好多時我都想解釋佢知,可惜佢地只會覺得我係縱容自己個仔囉。最近我同塱爸都因需唔需要好惡去教佢而有分歧,我覺得教唔一定要惡或以打指嚇,但塱爸覺得太仁慈,佢會唔驚,自小唔間中嚴下,大左佢更唔驚,塱塱出世到依家我都無打過佢,因為打始終唔係我接受既方法,好奇怪,唔知係咪仔親媽咪多d,我對梓塱唔惡,但又有種無名既威嚴,相反塱爸有時會嚴肅,只是我曾經講過覺得佢唔需要下下板起塊面咁去話佢,先有用,塱爸就勉強地不用惡的方式去教啦,但佢係口服心不服那種囉,只係順從我既做法,但不認同囉。塱爸個心始終覺得以前果套有時要嚴先得,但我見到幾次,佢惡住黎教梓塱,得出結果係佢越強硬,塱塱亦變得更頑固,其實梓塱比我感覺受軟唔受硬,再加上佢又唔係成日曳,所以我覺得無必要惡住咁教而嚇怕佢。唔好意思越講越長,你可以評論一下你對此既睇法嗎?
Dear Yuki
很感謝你跟我分享你的湊仔經…. 實在是獲益良多….
評論麻, 實在不敢當, 哪有資格!!! >.< 不過你既想法, 似乎比妹妹更正面, 絕對是好事麻!~~ 如果相信孩子是父母的倒模, 那…. 你應該要對自己有信心咯!!!!
“威嚴”問題, 似乎我也面對類似情況啊…
靖天不怕爸b, 卻怕我到極…
縱使爸b如何怪責, 她都是無動於衷…. 就當是”蝦爸爸”好了, …..
打不打問題……… 細個打下, 搏佢唔記得 (呵呵)
大個就唔好喇, ….. 俾人告虐兒架!!
“我”的概念我也是上完堂先知有o的咁既野…. 也感覺小孩不可能明白什麼叫”大話”, 現在, 就更了解一點咯!
之前都聽過呢個理論, 多謝呢個天深入既資料!
“天”?!
多謝指教!
打多左啫..
唔係呀, 2句係唔同意思呀
一問你”天”即係…..?!
二想你指教一下呀!!!
睇完你呢篇文覺得似曾相識tim但一時間諗唔起係邊度睇過呢套理論…睇過竟然唔記得, 總成日係度諗小朋友咁細個點解識講大話…
真係好多謝你既分享, 終於解決咗心中個疑問…
有理論打底, 易明一點, 嘻!!!!
多謝分享啊﹗你咁講,我先唸返起身邊有啲3-4歲既小朋友都有咁既行為,好多時都唔知佢地邊句真邊句假。
如果有此學說, 咁樣我地會變得大量o的, 嘻!